Skip to Main Content

Theory of Knowledge: Reason

ToK - a core component of the IBDP

Key Concepts

Deductive reasoning - Any form of reasoning that moves from the general to the particular

Truth and validity - Truth is concerned with what is the case, validity with whether conculsions follow from premises; truth is a property of statements, validity of arguments. 

Inductive reasoning - Inductive reasoning goes from the particular to the general.

Informal reasoning - post hoc ergo propter hoc - assumes that because one thing follows another, the latter is the cause of the former. 

Ad hominem - consists in attacking or supporting the person rather than the argument

Circular reasoning - consists in assuming the truth of something that you are supposed to be proving.

Ad ignorantium - is claiming something is true on the grounds that there is no evidence to disprove it

The importance of premises - If the truth of the conclusion depends on the truth of the premises, then we need to take a close look at what we use as premises.

Lateral thinking - Edward de Bono suggests that - since we cannot rely on traditional logic to give us new ideas, we need to adopt a more creative way of thinking that encourages us to search actively for better solutions to problems

Universal generalizations: precious, fragile statements

Is there more to rationalism than logic? According to some thinkers,logic has traditionally been seen as the academic's way of repairing the cognitive errors of the stupid....

Causal inference - Inference is a powerful move in reasoning: filling in the connections between pieces of information we already have, taking statements we already believe and from them pulling out more.

Classification Classification is a form of reasoning that groups concepts, ideas, and objects together into related categories, and gives them a collective term

from the IB studyguide

What is the difference between reason and logic? How reliable is inductive reasoning? Are we predictably irrational?

Reason allows us to go beyond the immediate experience of our senses. It is closely linked to logic—the deducing of valid conclusions from given starting points or premises. Human reasoning can also be inferential in nature, allowing conclusions to be drawn that cannot be strictly deduced from their premises. It then becomes an interesting question of whether standards of rationality and norms of reasoning are grounded in culture. Areas of knowledge might set their own requirements for the types of reasoning that are accepted.

Inductive reasoning is the process of supporting general statements by a series of particular ones—the reverse of deductive reasoning which tends to proceed from the general to the particular. Inductive reasoning is by its nature inferential. Statements involving the word “all” are often not strictly provable given the difficulties in making observations of an infinite set of particulars. This is of importance in the natural sciences but also in human sciences such as psychology and economics.

from: https://ibpublishing.ibo.org/exist/rest/app/tsm.xql?doc=d_0_tok_gui_1304_1_e&part=2&chapter=3

Interesting web articles

Videos about reason

Books about reasoning available in the Library

101 Ways to Score Higher on Your SAT Reasoning Test

Contains over one hundred tips and suggestions to improve SAT scores with step-by-step instructions to write better essays and reviews of grammar usage and math concepts, details a test-taking strategy that encourages time management and educated guessing, and provides resources for practice tests.

Psychology Basics, Revised Edition, Volume 2

Contains fifty-nine essays that provide information on significant theories and issues in the field of psychology, each with a list of sources for further study; arranged alphabetically from "Logic and Reasoning" to "Women's Psychology: Sigmund Freud,"

Thinking from A to Z

Contains alphabetically arranged entries that provide information about various aspects of critical thinking, covering common moves in argument, seductive reasoning errors, techniques of persuasion and avoidance, and psychological factors.

Labyrinths of Reason

A collection of classical philosophical thought puzzles and experiments that push language and reason to their logical limits.

Kant's Theory of Knowledge

Presents a comprehensive analysis to eighteenth-century philosopher, Immanuel Kant's "Critique of Pure Reason,"

Outliers

The author explores why some people are high achievers and others are not, citing culture, family, and upbringing as possible reasons some people are not as successful as others.

Think

Introduces some of the big themes of life, including knowledge, mind, free will, the self, God, reasoning, the world, and what to do; and shares what various philosophers from throughout the ages have had to say about each topic.

Reasons, Explanations, and Decisions

An introductory treatment of critical reasoning and logic. After discussing types of arguments, fallacies in argument, a and evaluations of arguments, a final chapter presents decision making strategies, including cases of uncertainty.

Quotes about reason

 ‘It has been said that man is a rational animal. All my life I have been searching for evidence which could support this.’ Bertrand Russell

'I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect has intended us to forgo their use.' Galileo Galilei

'He that will not reason is a bigot; he that cannot reason is a fool; and he that dares not reason is a slave.'  William Drummond

'Critical reason is the only alternative to violence so far discovered.'  Karl Popper

'Reason itself is a matter of faith. It is an act of faith to assert that our thoughts have any relation to reality at all.'  G K Chesterton

'You do not reason a man out of something he was not reasoned into' Jonathan Swift